Thought for the day: Take a deep breath

... And then step back from the ID card precipice before you do something we will all regret, Simon Moores urges the government

Simon Moores  

... And then step back from the ID card precipice before you do something we will all regret, Simon Moores urges the government




The CBI’s expression of support for national identity cards may be enough encouragement to breathe more life into another muddled and potentially expensive IT disaster.

Its deputy director general, John Cridland, is quite right to express concern that the absence of a national scheme makes the UK more vulnerable to criminals and terrorists. But the Home Office, which plans to introduce  biometric cards by 2007 and make them compulsory by 2013, needs little encouragement in its blundering attempts to drive through a solution that all civil-libertarians, many MPs and most technologists doubt can deliver the economic and security benefits that David Blunkett imagines.

Where Cridland goes wrong is saying, "ID cards could improve security and make access to public services more efficient. Companies want ID cards to be a universal identity-authentication system.”

Most of us would like to see world peace and a cure for cancer and the same may be said for the benefits promised on behalf of identity cards. After all, in the many countries that have them - even biometric cards - crime and terrorism simply find new mechanisms to circumvent the inconvenience of having to produce a piece of plastic on demand.

It is not just the cards that are a worry, because they represent the tip of the iceberg. It is the data that lies behind the identity system: how it is captured, how it is stored and how it is shared. I wonder how many readers would, if asked, trust the government - any government - with that information.

After all, mistakes are inevitable in any large data-based system, my own postcode being one small example: you try convincing an insurance company or a mortgage lender that the Royal Mail has given you the wrong postcode for your address, when they input your details on to a screen.

One problem is that government, as always, is being dazzled by the promises of the big IT companies, like one I met with last month.

It is keen to be involved in any national scheme because it is very good at the ID-card technology and has a strong record in the US. Which is nice - but what it actually seemed to be saying is that it can deliver the mix of technology that can embed biometric information on a plastic square and store that information on a database, which operates at a rather different scale to having a national system with tens of millions of users and all the rights and privacy regulations that will complicate such a system.

Following the debate over the past 12 months I still see nothing that gives me any confidence that our plans for a UK national ID card - or entitlement card - will achieve any security or other objectives beyond wasting another billion pounds or so of taxpayer’s money.

As a society, we need to stop, take a deep breath and then revisit the identity proposition with real consultation and open debate, not the recent hurried urgency and insistence that nanny is right and everyone else is wrong.

Rather than offering crumbs of comfort to a government hell-bent on delivering a badly-considered solution to a pressing economic and security problem, organisations such as the CBI, the Institute of Directors and others should be putting their weight behind a common sense call for a moratorium on the project.

Otherwise the UK will find itself with a half-baked solution that achieves very little and that we will all live to regret.

Setting the world to rights with the collected thoughts and opinions of leading industry analyst Dr Simon Moores of Zentelligence.

Acting globally, Zentelligence (Research) advises governments, suppliers, business and the media on the evolution, application and delivery of leading-edge technologies, and specialises in the areas of e-government and information security.

For further information on Zentelligence and its research, presentation and analyst services, visit

Read more on Identity and access management products