You are here  IT Management Legislation and Regulation

Labour under fire over its Internet tactics

Friday 01 June 2001 07:21
Liberal Democrats have vowed to stop Labour using "unethical" techniques to divert Internet traffic to its web site.

The Labour Party has used web site metatags - the practice of submitting key words such as "William Hague, law and order" - to Internet search engines in a bid to pull traffic away from Tory, Liberal Democrat, Scottish National Party, Plaid Cymru and Green Party web sites.

It is deemed to be poor Internet convention for an organisation to submit the key words associated with a rival to direct web traffic to its site.

The practice has been condemned by the Conservative Party and Liberal Democrats and denounced as unethical and immoral by Lars Davis, Professor of Internet law at Queen Mary College, University of London.

Opposition parties cried foul when CW360.com informed them of the practice.

Lib Dem IT spokesman Richard Allan MP promised to make Labour change its metatags.

He said, "This demonstrates that the Labour Party will use any tactic to gain an edge. They should remember that we do have responsibilities as political parties. Enough people are disillusioned with politics without the government perverting a new form of information technology for their own needs."


A Conservative Party spokesman said, "This is typical of New Labour. Deceiving people and conning the public into listening to what they have to say."

Lars Davies, Professor of Internet law at Queen Mary College, University of London, told CW360.com that Labour's actions were not illegal but would probably be considered as "passing off" under law if it were operating in the commercial world.

"There are stringent tests for liability when you are using a competitor's name and trademark as a metatag on your web site," said Davies. "This bid to emulate the bad practices in the commercial world is highly unethical and immoral."

Commercial organisations' use of metatags has become a contentious legal issue as cases of misuse have come to light.

Last year, the High Court ordered IT supplier Mandata to pay £15,000 damages after it included trademarks belonging to rival Roadtech Computer Systems in its metatags.

In January, Orbys Consulting was forced to change its metatags after being threatened with legal action for trademark infringement of IT services giant EDS and outsourcing consultancy Morgan Chambers.

Metatags used on the Labour Party web site include Conservative, Tory, William Hague, SNP, Plaid Cymru, Lib Dems Green.

The Labour Party failed to comment to several enquiries by CW360.Com.
Bruce Ackland