The results of the latest Goldman Sachs IT Spending Survey, based on interviews with 300 IT directors from major European companies and 100 US IT chiefs, suggests that IT budgets in Europe will decline by an average of 3% in 2003 and a further 2% in 2004.
Nearly 75% of European IT directors do not expect to see their IT budgets grow by more than 5% for at least five years.
The decline contrasts with "increased optimism" and a projected growth in IT budgets of 3.5% next year among IT directors in the US. Twenty five per cent of those polled predicted IT spending growth of 10% or more.
More than 50% of the European IT professionals questioned said they had deferred IT projects up to four times this year due to budgetary limits. Of those who had postponed projects during 2003, 40% said they would postpone them until at least 2004, with a further 36% uncertain when the projects would be realised.
David Roberts, chief executive of the Corporate IT Forum, said Goldman Sachs' European findings were in-line with the belt-tightening experiences of many large IT users in the UK. "I would certainly expect budgets to be flat because if there is any way an organisation can make budgets decline, it will do that," he said.
But the disparity between the US and European figures could be the result of "false optimism" following the war in Iraq and analysts believe this "Baghdad bounce" could be short-lived.
Anthony Miller research director at analyst firm Ovum, said he would be surprised if the US market recovered as quickly as Goldman Sachs suggests. "I think they are either being far too positive or just plain daft. There is nothing new on the horizon, whether a technology or an event. It is a mystery to me."
Jamie Snowdon, an analyst at IDC, said the difference between the US and European figures could be down to differences in attitude. "They are quicker to respond to changes in market conditions and their business outlook is more optimistic," he said. "We are a bit more cautious in Europe and the UK is somewhere in between."
Goldman Sachs said it sees potential for some upturn in investment in Europe in 2004. Key areas will be security, disaster recovery and outsourcing.