Google and Yahoo top e-business poll

Google and Yahoo have been identified as two of the outstanding websites in an e-business survey carried out for the University...

Google and Yahoo have been identified as two of the outstanding websites in an e-business survey carried out for the University of Michigan.

The study, which measures the top 200 companies in this sector during the second quarter of each year, shows that America Online, though still not a top performer, has made a dramatic improvement in the past year and may be on the way to attracting more customers.

Overall, the ACSI e-business industry score improved year on year, up from 68.7 (on a scale of 0-100) in 2002 to a score of 71.4 this year.

Google consistently places at the top of the search engine category; it had a score of 82 this year, while Ask Jeeves improved its performance by seven points, to 69, according to the study. Search engine Alta Vista trailed its competitors with a score of 63.

Google's score shows that it has one of the strongest relationships with its customers of any kind of company, online or offline, said ForeSee chief executive officer Larry Freed, whose company is an e-business partner with the university.

In the portal category, AOL made a dramatic six-point jump in performance, bringing its score to 65.

Yahoo is still the dominant player in this category with a score of 78, a two-point improvement on last year, and MSN also moved up two points to 74.

"AOL's improvement is very, very impressive," said Freed. "People have said AOL was down for the count before and have been proved wrong."

In the news and information category, and tied with 74 points, followed closely by and, which tied at 72. brings up the rear again this year with a score of 70, down one point from last year.

"News sites show every sign of being, basically, a mature industry," Freed said. "The innovation that we see coming from hypercompetitiveness in so many online industries just doesn't exist in the news field."

Freed said two clear trends are emerging.

First, two of the three categories - search engines and portals - have clearly dominant players, though for laggers in the portal category, at least, catching up with Yahoo seems possible.

However, he said, in the search engine category, for other search engines to pull alongside or surpass Google seems like a long shot.

Second, companies in the portal and search categories that lead their fields - and are leaders in e-business in general - are doing a good job of evolving their business models without losing customer satisfaction, loyalty and brand power.

"It is almost certainly not a coincidence that very strong customer satisfaction scores and the continued upward trajectory of these scores is happening in categories [search engines, portals] that did not exist before the internet, despite continuing evolution of business model," Freed said.

Linda Rosencrance writes for Computerworld

Read more on E-commerce technology