Allow market forces to let the UK Broadband to catch up with the rest of the world

The main message from the Conservative Technology Form meeting on Broadband was that officials  still appear to be seeking to defend past decisions rather than admit that their idionsyncratic and equivocal guidance on what is, or is not, state aid are still blocking the public-private partnerships that are bringing 100 mbps, symmetric, and more, to small firms, not just consumers, across the rest of the EU.

They do not wish to have to admit that market forces can be used to address regulatory failure, provided that the communications needs (and budgets) of business and government are brought together to support funding models for new investment that are successfull in other parts of the world.

They do they wish to have to admit that even the French have used the devolution of authority to local government to succeed where central government had failed. The results are patchy, but even the worst departements, usually those which decided to allow the incumbent to retain its effective monopoly, are doing as well as the best UK counties. 

 

It will be interesting to see what is announced as part of the spending review. Some very well briefed MPs will be asking some very pointed PQs, if their quiet words with the Minister do not lead to rapid action.

It was particularly interesting to hear so many speakers saying that the problem is not the money. It is making good use of the money we already have. I liked the comment from that back on the need to make it attractive for BT to organise a public share issue so that those who bought shares when it was privatised can help fund much more ambitious investment plans than at present: Compare BT’s current  £2.5 billion programme with the scale and pace of its fibre roll out before the introduction of local loop unbundling, to prevent the NTL and Telewest from being wiped out. Compare it with the amounts trousered by Treasury after the first great spectrum auction. Compare it with government’s annual spend on its current crumbling telecoms operations (military and civil, voice and data, health, education , welfare delivery etc. etc.). Compare it with the revenues of Google UK.

The point was made several times that it was not BT v. the rest.

There is more than enough demand for all – and many local areas can be served better and more cheaply than by diverting BT time and attention from that which will give better return to its shareholders.

We needed BT to generate far more revenue from the on-line content and advertising industry by removing the back haul bottlenecks that demand for their services has created. Without that investment, fibre in the last mile is little better than a cheap replacement for the copper that is increasingly being stolen as the price of scrap soars.   

All in all – there was much food for thought. The meeting was recorded but I do not think there were any plans  to produce a report. I hope, however, that the tapes will be put on-line and will post the link if they are. 

 

Join the conversation

6 comments

Send me notifications when other members comment.

Please create a username to comment.

Philip,

Were there any other IT oriented fringe meetings other than the Conservative Technology Forum? A few years ago, when I attended all the party conferences, there used to be three or four. And it is all only a few years ago, that Erich Schmidt of Google gave a plenary talk for the Tories.

I get the impression that the party conferences are becoming more and more IT-free zones. This is mad, at a time that the Web, social networking and the free-up of Government data is changing the political process for ever. And, incidentally, providing the tools to build the Big Society. Politicians do not seem to have grasped this yet.

Comment by Philip Virgo: Information Systems are now mainstream in the sense that everyone was talking about mash-ups, i-phones, broadband, and mobiles being used to transform the delivery of public services. However, the term "Information Technology" was only used to preface an attack on failed systems and "the past". If it works it is taken for granted. If it does not, it is yet another example of the iniquities of the IT industry. Is that success or failure?

Cancel
Yeah, Ok, everybody may have been talking about mash-ups etc, but were they talking about these tools in a coherent way, or taking into account that many of these tools have been used for five years or more by outfits like FixMyStreet or Patient Opinion or Mumsnet. Has anybody asked these how they would see the Big Society develop. They know.

In answer to my original question about whether there were other IT fringe meetings, I have done a quick google trawl and found none at the Tory conference.

Comment from Philip VIrgo: None mentioned ICT in the headline but most of those on Big Society, Public Service and Social Inclusion had ICT issues at their heart. Bear in mind the other Ancient Chinese curse: about getting what you wish for - including being taken seriously.

Cancel
Yeah, Ok, everybody may have been talking about mash-ups etc, but were they talking about these tools in a coherent way, or taking into account that many of these tools have been used for five years or more by outfits like FixMyStreet or Patient Opinion or Mumsnet. Has anybody asked these how they would see the Big Society develop. They know.In answer to my original question about whether there were other IT fringe meetings, I have done a quick google trawl and found none at the Tory conference.Comment from Philip VIrgo: None mentioned ICT in the headline but most of those on Big Society, Public Service and Social Inclusion had ICT issues at their heart. Bear in mind the other Ancient Chinese curse: about getting what you wish for - including being taken seriously.
Cancel
Yeah, Ok, everybody may have been talking about mash-ups etc, but were they talking about these tools in a coherent way, or taking into account that many of these tools have been used for five years or more by outfits like FixMyStreet or Patient Opinion or Mumsnet. Has anybody asked these how they would see the Big Society develop. They know.In answer to my original question about whether there were other IT fringe meetings, I have done a quick google trawl and found none at the Tory conference.Comment from Philip VIrgo: None mentioned ICT in the headline but most of those on Big Society, Public Service and Social Inclusion had ICT issues at their heart. Bear in mind the other Ancient Chinese curse: about getting what you wish for - including being taken seriously.
Cancel
Yeah, Ok, everybody may have been talking about mash-ups etc, but were they talking about these tools in a coherent way, or taking into account that many of these tools have been used for five years or more by outfits like FixMyStreet or Patient Opinion or Mumsnet. Has anybody asked these how they would see the Big Society develop. They know.

In answer to my original question about whether there were other IT fringe meetings, I have done a quick google trawl and found none at the Tory conference.

Comment from Philip VIrgo: None mentioned ICT in the headline but most of those on Big Society, Public Service and Social Inclusion had ICT issues at their heart. Bear in mind the other Ancient Chinese curse: about getting what you wish for - including being taken seriously.
Cancel
Yeah, Ok, everybody may have been talking about mash-ups etc, but were they talking about these tools in a coherent way, or taking into account that many of these tools have been used for five years or more by outfits like FixMyStreet or Patient Opinion or Mumsnet. Has anybody asked these how they would see the Big Society develop. They know.

In answer to my original question about whether there were other IT fringe meetings, I have done a quick google trawl and found none at the Tory conference.

Comment from Philip VIrgo: None mentioned ICT in the headline but most of those on Big Society, Public Service and Social Inclusion had ICT issues at their heart. Bear in mind the other Ancient Chinese curse: about getting what you wish for - including being taken seriously.
Cancel

-ADS BY GOOGLE

SearchCIO

SearchSecurity

SearchNetworking

SearchDataCenter

SearchDataManagement

Close