Contractors suffer another blow in IR35 case

The High Court dealt a blow to self-employed IT contractors today (28 March) when it threw out a legal challenge to the Inland...

The High Court dealt a blow to self-employed IT contractors today (28 March) when it threw out a legal challenge to the Inland Revenue over its controversial IR35 tax.

A judge dismissed a claim by former police officer Gordon Stutchbury against a tax ruling that forced him to pay more than half of his company’s turnover to the Inland Revenue.

The IR35 tax, which prevents contractors from offsetting more than 5% of their income against tax, has proved unpopular both with contractors and employers, who fear it will push up contractor rates.

The decision, described by Stutchbury’s supporters as “a bitter blow", leaves confusion over the tax law, and may make it difficult for the self-employed to predict what work will be taxed under IR35 and what work is exempt.

“It is clearly disappointing and as anyone who’s ever run a business knows, this sort of confusion adds to the pressures and uncertainties.

"It’s almost impossible to run a business on that basis,” said Stutchbury, speaking after the judgment.

Stutchbury, who was backed by the Professional Contractors Group, brought the case after it was ruled that he was subject to the tax despite being “in business on his own account”.

Observers have suggested that Stuchbury’s case may have been damaged by his decision to represent himself before the authorities, rather than hire a legal representative.

His company, Synaptek, provided services to around 20 clients and employed up to four people.

The Professional Contractors Group has 14 days to consider an appeal.

Read more on IT for small and medium-sized enterprises (SME)

Start the conversation

Send me notifications when other members comment.

Please create a username to comment.






  • How do I size a UPS unit?

    Your data center UPS sizing needs are dependent on a variety of factors. Develop configurations and determine the estimated UPS ...

  • How to enhance FTP server security

    If you still use FTP servers in your organization, use IP address whitelists, login restrictions and data encryption -- and just ...

  • 3 ways to approach cloud bursting

    With different cloud bursting techniques and tools from Amazon, Zerto, VMware and Oracle, admins can bolster cloud connections ...