IT expenditure by HM Revenue & Customs is set to reach £8.5bn over the next 10 years, almost triple original estimates.
Matters have not been helped by the high costs associated with changing suppliers that weren’t delivering in the eyes of HMRC, said the Commons Public Accounts Committee (PAC).
ASPIRE (Acquiring Strategic Partners for the Inland Revenue) is HMRC’s contract with Capgemini for the provision of IT services.
Edward Leigh MP, chairman of the PAC, said, “The re-competition of the IT services for the former Inland Revenue ended with the incumbent suppliers, EDS and Accenture, being replaced by Capgemini.
“The transition was successful but very costly. It is hard to find a justification for HMRC paying so much, nearly £52m, towards bidders’ costs to encourage competition. Any department doing this in future must show there is no other cost-effective way of securing competition.”
Leigh added, “HMRC could also have been sharper in its negotiations. The actual costs of transition were agreed after the contract was awarded and competitive tension had vanished – and the costs even included a profit margin for the successful bidder.”
Leigh said, “There has been a very steep rise in HMRC’s spending on IT services – the forecast figure is some £8.5bn over the ten years of the contract compared with the original estimate of nearly £3bn. If profit margins carry on at the current level, then Capgemini could make £1.1bn on the contract, nearly four times the amount originally envisaged.”
Leigh said HMRC should have foreseen that its demand for IT services could vary significantly and determined how this might affect its contractor’s prices and profit margins. He said these will have to be “rigorously benchmarked” in future to make sure the prices fairly reflect the actual volume of work being carried out.
Comment on this article: [email protected]