Will intra company transfer loophole be closed in immigration cap report next month?

A report being put together by the Migration Advisory Committee (MAC) about the immigration cap will be published some time in October. But will it include the dreaded Intra Company Transfer (ICT) loophole within its scope?

One campaigner for reform to ICTs told me today: “The MAC’s task is incedibly difficult. The government’s target, [to cut immigration], will be very hard to achieve and unless ICTs are included in the cap or the ICT numbers excluded from the immigration figures, then it will be impossible.”

I was expecting the report this month but as it is the last day I put a call in to the Home Office. A spokeswoman told me the much anticipated report will be out next month. But there was no exact date.

The report is expected to be used by the government when it devises its immigration cap which will replace the current interim one in April.

Campaigners who claim that the immigration system is abused to allow overseas IT workers into the UK want the final cap to be different to the interim one which they believe is nonsensical.

The interim cap does not include workers in the UK on ICTs, which actually account for thousands and IT workers are by far and a way the largest part of this group.

See how many immigrant workers are in the UK and what they are doing as well as how many are in on ICTs here.

ICTs were created to allow very senior staff at large US companies to work in the UK without too many hurdles. But over time many low skilled jobs have been included and IT staff in the UK are losing their jobs to overseas workers who even come to the UK to be trained to replace UK them.

The issue was raised the other night by 5 Live investigates. Listen to the broadcast it was included on in this podcast.

It has also unearthed divisions in the coalition government with Vince Cable speaking out against the cap. The Liberals were against the cap but it survived coalition talks.

There are accusations that the ICT immigration loophole is destroying the UK IT profession, although many believe it is just changing it.

According to Sir Andrew Green of Migration Watch, while speaking at a recent Home Affairs Select Committee which discussed immigration the use of Intra Company Transfers (ICTs) to bring in workers from overseas is a major cause of the high rate of unemployment amongst computer science graduates, which is 17% for those that graduated last year.

Join the conversation


Send me notifications when other members comment.

Please create a username to comment.

The immigration cap and ICT loophole are two separate issues.

The ICT route might not be capped but the rules and policing could be improved, which would please many people.

The route might be changed to take it out of immigrations figures (e.g. by turning it into an under 1 year but renewable visa), which would change nothing but cut the reported figures.


Vacancy from Jobcentre Plus

Job No:



£12000 TO £15500 PER ANNUM







Date posted

07 October 2010

Closing date

04 November 2010

Pension details

Pension available


An exciting opportunity has arisen at the Stockton office of this dynamic, progressive and expanding business. The company work within e-learning offering Educational establishments and businesses an established yet growing portfolio of on-line Education and Training solutions. Already established in the UK, the company is still growing in this market and is. now pushing in to several other countries.As a key part of their continued growth our client seeks .Net Developer and Report Writer. Applicants must have an IT related degree and at least 1 year of commercial experience performing basic VB and Visual Studio development and or report writing experience using SQL or Crystal Reports, ideally working with Tables, Graphs and Web Pages for Forms. The successful applicant can look forward to training and support. Apply to ....co.uk.

How to apply

You can apply for this job by visiting ....co.uk and following the instructions on the webpage.


12k for a graduate developer with a year's experience. I have a suspicion that this company are planning to import a foreign worker to fill this role.

How many other professions could employers get away with this kind of piss taking behaviour?