One easy way to access this blog

From Google key in: tony collins blog

To comment anonymously on any blog entry, leave blank the fields in the comment form that ask for the email address and other details. If these are left blank we don’t know who the emailer is.

Join the conversation


Send me notifications when other members comment.

Please create a username to comment.

Read your CSC piece with interest. I've just heard that CSC may be about to experience problems with their other supplier. TPP have not filed accounts yet, long overdue, leading to speculation that they also could be having problems.

All valid points. But having helped structure, close and finance a number of PFI/PPP backed IT deals I think the key failing is in fact that old favourite: scope creep.

Consider Inland Revenue sorry HM Revenue & Customs, forced to outsource core IT support under a 10 year fixed price pay for output contract. Of course the Chancellor can't be clear on scope as (s)he reserves the right to change the fundamental tax law every year (eg working tax credit introduction) and requires this be implemented with x months notice.

Would BP say or GSK ever try a fundamental global restructuring of their business every year for a decade and not expect that (a) staff would become "change survivors" rather than enablers or (b) infrastructure costs might rise?

Would any road builder under a PFI/PPP price, or deliver, anything close to time or budget if the contract is say London to Oxford but might, with 3 months notice, become London to Canterbury?

It's actually a miracle that PFI/PPP in public sector IT delivers ANYTHING at all.

Remember the rules of thumb: time and material becomes fixed price? Double the quote. Scope unclear? Double the quote again and try and make everything undefined "out of scope" at penal time and material rates. 10 years financing at 10% cost of capital with PFI/PPP? Double or triple the quote again. That "simple" £50m change programme just became £400m - £600m and rising.

The losers - current and future tax payers. The only winners, sadly, are the lawyers and the bankers

From a Sad taxpayer and ex PFI/PPP financier.