Zuckerberg commits to Facebook becoming privacy-focused

A note on encryption

In a note on encryption, Zuckerberg said end-to-end encryption is an important tool in developing a privacy-focused social network because it protects users from intrusions by hackers, criminals, over-reaching governments and even operators of the social network.

However, he said there are “real safety concerns” to address before Facebook can implement end-to-end encryption across all of its messaging services.

“Encryption is a powerful tool for privacy, but that includes the privacy of people doing bad things. When billions of people use a service to connect, some of them are going to misuse it for truly terrible things like child exploitation, terrorism, and extortion. We have a responsibility to work with law enforcement and to help prevent these wherever we can.”

Zuckerberg said Facebook is working to improve its ability to identify and stop bad actors by detecting patterns of activity or through other means. “But we face an inherent tradeoff because we will never find all of the potential harm we do today when our security systems can see the messages themselves.”

Finding the right ways to protect both privacy and safety is something societies have historically grappled with, he said, adding that Facebook will consult with safety experts, law enforcement and governments on the best ways to implement safety measures.

“We'll also need to work together with other platforms to make sure that as an industry we get this right. The more we can create a common approach, the better,” said Zuckerberg. “On balance, I believe working towards implementing end-to-end encryption for all private communications is the right thing to do.”

Outlined principles

Over the next year and beyond, he said there are a lot more details and tradeoffs to work through related to each of the principles he outlined.

“A lot of this work is in the early stages, and we are committed to consulting with experts, advocates, industry partners, and governments -- including law enforcement and regulators -- around the world to get these decisions right.”

Zuckerberg said Facebook will work towards a world where people can speak privately and live freely knowing that their information will only be seen by who they want to see it and will not stick around forever.

While some commentators see the announcement as a sign that Facebook leadership is finally recognising what users want, the planned changes have not been welcomed by everyone.

Some critics see the proposed changes as a way of enabling Facebook to abandon its responsibilities, according to the BBC, because if Facebook is more private and temporary, it may be more difficult to hold the social network accountable for any perceived misdeeds.

Those with a more cynical view believe Zuckerberg has simply recognised a business opportunity and is seeking to pursue it, while at the same time seeking to avoid falling foul of new and emerging privacy legislation around the world, realising that failure to do so could ultimately see Facebook fail.

Statutory enquiries

It recently emerged that the Irish Data Protection Commission (DPC) alone opened 10 statutory inquiries into Facebook and other Facebook-owned platforms in the first seven months since the European General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) came into force on 25 May 2018.

In another recent revelation, it emerged that Sheryl Sandberg, chief operating officer of Facebook, asked George Osborne while he was the UK’s chancellor of the exchequer to be “even more active and vocal” in his concerns about European data protection legislation, and to “really help shape the proposals”, during a lobbying campaign to influence EU policy.

The meeting took place at the World Economic Forum (WEF) in 2013 as top Facebook executives sought to influence politicians and policy-makers over European plans to introduce tougher privacy and data protection laws, a Computer Weekly report revealed.

Sandberg also sought assurances from Canada’s minister of industry, Christian Paradis, over embryonic plans by the company to build a datacentre in the country, according to company documents seen by Computer Week and The Observer.