NAN - Fotolia
The Home Office’s ability to update and maintain its border, policing and immigration IT systems could be compromised, following a wide-scale reclassification of its contractors as inside IR35, it is claimed.
Under the new IR35 legislation, which came into force on 6 April, responsibility for determining if limited company contractors should be taxed in the same way as salaried employees (inside IR35) or off-payroll staff (outside IR35) now lies with the public sector bodies they engage with. Previously, it was down to the contractor to self-declare their tax status.
The Home Office is understood to have enlisted a third-party IR35 contract review provider to assess the engagements of its off-payroll workers several weeks ago.
This process resulted in the “vast majority” of Home Office IT contractors being initially declared outside IR35, sources claim.
A subsequent and unexpected reassessment of their engagements, however, has since seen them ruled inside IR35, Computer Weekly has learned, prompting contractors working on several key Home Office IT systems to walk out.
“A whole bunch of folks who had their assessments done, and had email confirmation they were outside, were suddenly reassessed. This has put the cat amongst the pigeons,” a former Home Office IT contractor, who left in the wake of the reassessments, told Computer Weekly.
“Entire teams have been taken out, and there are still people who’ve not had their assessments back and don’t know what they’re walking into when they turn up to work.”
Tax status turnaround
The U-turn is understood to have created a lot of bad feeling in the department, another IT contractor caught up in the furore told Computer Weekly.
“It has screwed contractors who know they are outside and now have the last-minute option of either walking out the door or being forced onto PAYE for no reason until they can line up another contractor gig and flee the Home Office,” they said.
Among those hit by the departures are the teams overseeing the delivery of the Home Office’s Common Data Platform (CDP) and Core Technical Infrastructure (CTI) capabilities, Computer Weekly understands.
“The Home Office can try to build up its own capacity, to replace those who have left, but it will take a long time to skill people up, and the Civil Service doesn’t currently have the technology skills the department needs,” the source added.
Read more about IR35
- HMRC has begun classifying its public sector contractors as “inside IR35”, prompting fears of a digital “brain drain” at the organisation.
- HM Revenue & Customs (HMRC) has underestimated the widescale disruption the IR35 tax avoidance reforms will have on the delivery of public sector IT projects, as stakeholders warn that the number of contractors affected will dwarf department estimates.
According to the Home Office’s own technology strategy document, the CDP enables the organisation to securely access and share data across multiple departmental systems.
A sudden shortfall in contractor support for these systems could have a knock-on impact on core policing, border control and immigration-related IT systems, it is feared.
“The local managers in charge of those teams have specific deadline objectives and are likely to be cursing what’s gone on,” said the first source.
“Even if they start advertising for replacement staff today, they’re still going to be losing six, eight or 12 weeks of work on their projects because that’s how long it could take to get a recruitment advert done, approved and circulated to start interviewing to fill the vacancies.”
IT delivery delay fears
The timing of the departures could not be worse, said the second source. “Why do this now, with borders, immigration, visas [all areas] where Brexit will hit hard and require the best talent the Home Office can find?”
In an interview with Computer Weekly in March 2017, Home Office CIO Sarah Wilkinson described the department as “enormously dependent” on off-payroll workers, and spoke candidly about how the IR35 reforms would affect the delivery of public sector projects.
“There’s no doubt in my mind that, if we’re realistic, we’re going to have a year of significant pain, because you will see a degradation of the contractor population,” she said.
“It will take some time to embed new pay structures even if they were approved tomorrow. It would take some time to recruit even if we started tomorrow. So 2017 is going to be extraordinarily difficult.
“I don’t know if there is a way of imagining the IR35 problem isn’t going to have a delivery impact, but once it’s done, it’s done. That’s the positive of it,” she said.
Reforms aiming to achieve fairness
Computer Weekly contacted the Home Office for a response to this story, and was issued with the following statement from a government spokesperson:
“Public sector organisations and contractors are free to work with each other in a manner that suits their circumstances, but it’s fair that two people doing the same job should pay the same taxes. These reforms will help ensure that happens,” said the statement.
“Like all tax changes, we are monitoring their effect to make sure they work effectively and fairly.”
Read more on IT for government and public sector
Defra confirms final settlement of £86.5m with HMRC over ‘historic’ IR35 status assessment errors
HMRC to review how IR35 works in practice following PAC criticism
Public sector bodies accused of freezing out SME IT consultancies over IR35 compliance fears
IR35 reforms: Private sector warned HMRC's 12-month 'light-touch' enforcement period is ending