So much for the rule of law?

| No Comments
| More

I was very disturbed to read the Guardian's claim that the police have been instructed by the Home Office to ignore the European Court's ruling that the UK DNA Database breaches human rights law, and instead continue to add information on arrestees to the database:

Senior police officers have also been "strongly advised" that it is "vitally important" that they resist individual requests based on the Strasbourg ruling to remove DNA profiles from the national database in cases such as wrongful arrest, mistaken identity, or where no crime has been committed.

Approximately 10% of the UK population is already recorded in the DNA Database, and that number continues to rise rapidly. I've talked in the past about why this disturbs me - it's not the DNA data itself, but the ability to track familial links, coupled with the inevitable failure of the forensic process for using that data, that will lead to injustice. This latest development is even more worrying, since allegedly senior police officers are obeying Home Office officials rather than the rule of law. If a member of the armed forces is issued an order which they believe to be unlawful, it is their duty to disregard the order and escalate their grievance up the chain of command. Does that not apply to the police in the UK? Or are they now above the law?

[Apologies for going all Daily Express letters page on you all, it's one of those weeks...]

Leave a comment

Disclaimer

The views expressed in this blog are my own, and do not necessarily reflect those of any client or other organisation.

Subscribe to blog feed

Archives

Categories

Toby on Twitter

    Recent Comments

    HarringtonMa on A week when databases go ... : Open this ESSAYSEMPIRE company and purchase excel...
    David Moss on Postcodes, PAF and Pseudo... : 1. In view of the above, amused to remember earlie...
    Wayne Scott on Postcodes, PAF and Pseudo... : It’ll be tough with the current mail sortation tec...
    David Moss on Could Identity Assurance ... : I agree with Philip. To adapt Crosby's marvellous...
    Philip Virgo on Could Identity Assurance ... : Thoughtful as always but what about the lack of tr...
    Steve Wreyfo on Could Identity Assurance ... : Interesting post Toby, as ever, though needs to be...
    David Moss on Real Time Identity?... : This article originally appeared in the ICAEW's Ch...
    Lance Piper on Identity Assurance: Risk-... : Quarkside published some ideas for finely tuning l...
    Toby Stevens on Identity Assurance: Who, ... : Raj, good questions and ones I'll try to answer in...
    Muttukrishna on Identity Assurance: Who, ... : Thanks Toby for the interesting summary. Some ques...

     

    -- Advertisement --